Posted by: Joe A. () on Mon Sep 24 06:52:20 2001

>>> Unfortunately there are so many errors in the information on this site, especially in the frame-by-frame and the text that goes with it.--- On more then one occassion I have pointed out to Jack specific items that I consider errors and why I think they are errors and not once did I receive an answer addressing my concerns.
> <<<
>
> Joe A.
>
> I have no problem with a post that has an opinion on the swing that differs from my own. I think allowing opposing views brings an interesting discussion to this board that virtually all other boards shy away from. As I have repeatedly said, a good debate among gentlemen is a benefit to all. But I do take great issue when you state that there are "many errors in the information on this site" without addressing those errors you claim to have found.
>
> Joe, you have made a serious charge against this site and I am offering you an opportunity to defend your statement by pointing out all of the errors that you say you found. For your charges to remain properly focused, I will only respond to one "so called error" at a time. Once that charge has been dispensed with, you can then bring up another. --- Joe, the integrity of this site is important to me and therefore, I will not accept a post from you on any other subject until this matter has been resolved (in this thread).
>
> Jack Mankin

Jack,

I have already stated one specific error on the frame-by-frame. The text of the frame by frame states that the torso, hipt and shoulders, turn at the same time. I have listed 4 specific reasons this is in error and that the hips are the first part of the torson that turns.

In a responde you stated that that I was "preaching to the choir" implying that you agreed with me that the hips turn first. But you also stated that you would add the words "in unison" to the text. I took this to mean that the hips and shoulders turn "in unison." In a response I clarified my position and asked for your response. I have not received one.

I await your reply.

Joe A.