Posted by: Joe Hernandez (coach2hit@yahoo.com) on Fri Jun 2 20:17:46 2006

Gentlemen,

I have decided to put my two cents to your discussion. Rather than just list the benefits and drawbacks, I will try to explain my reasoning as well...so here goes, first with the benefits.

Benefit

In linear hitting (weight shift system) the first benefit is an increase in batting averages relative to a hitter's own hitting potential. Because the barrel of the bat is in the "contact" zone a bit longer, it does not become as imperative to "time" the pitch perfectly and yet still make solid contact. The second benefit from this is that it will put the hitter on base more frequently and reduce his strikeouts ratio.

As it was stated before, the hitter will have a greater possibility to hit to all fields because linear mechanics will enable the hitter to have good coverage of the plate. This alone creates more trouble for the defense as they try to adjust to such a hitter...all this spells more "openings" to get the ball through.

Another great advantage is that for a right-handed hitter, it enables him to get a good jump out of the batter's box simply because his body is already moving in that direction...at least with far less rotation than in the rotational system. Getting out of the batters box quicker can add a full step for the hitter and cut down the amount of times that a hitter experiences being thrown out at first by a half of step.


Drawbacks

As stated before me, reduced power is the most obvious and major drawback. But less consider some other drawbacks...there is the potential to move your head too much, this can impair your vision somewhat and hence not see the ball as well. If your head is moving, then your eyes are moving as well and this will create the optical illusion of the ball moving faster because it is difficult to track the ball while your head is moving.

With regards to different pitches, it only becomes a problem, and it can be a big problem, if the hitter has trouble distinguishing different types of pitches. The hitter can find himself committed to a pitch, then if fooled, he will be flailing at a pitch with just one arm or if the hitter is one to release the top hand, then he will find himself with only his bottom hand to drive the ball...how often have you seen this?

Letting go with the top hand can have a negative effect of bat velocity for reasons that are explain all through this website.

I am not in complete agreement with some of the drawbacks on hitting certain pitches. I do feel, and many studies have been done to show, that in linear mechanics you increase the odds of having difficulty hitting the inside and also the high strikes. Those that are quick with their hips and hands might be able to adjust and drive the inside pitch. Some have suggested that the hitter can shorten the "arc", thereby not extending completely the arms, to try to get the barrel of the bat on the ball much earlier (in front) before it reaches the plate.

However, you will find many exceptions to all of this from many great hitters. But from a statistical point of view these will be the benefits and drawbacks of the linear hitting system....at least by my experience as a player, coach and from observing hundreds of hours of videos. Just don't forget that there is an "art" to the science and a science to the art...with some that are exception to the rule, but many are not.

Thanks for allowing me my input.



> > > Benefits
> > > 1. a simple swing and approach
> > > 2. less likely to go into prolonged slumps
> > > 3. greater contact on fastballs
> > > 4. easier to use the hole field
> > > 5. uses more upper body strength
> > > 6. easier to hit the high pitch
> > >
> > > Flaws
> > > 1. decreased power
> > > 2. harder to hit the low pitch
> > > 3. harder to breaking pitches
> > > 4. tendency to hit the ball off the end of the bat
> > > 5. less batspeed
> > > 6. tendency to pull off pitches due to lack of batspeed
> >
> >
> > Hi hitman
> >
> > Im will have to disagree with some of your benefits and flaws of linier hitting this would be my list of benefits and flaws
> >
> > Benefits
> >
> > 1. simple swing
> > 2. easier to hit the high pitch
> >
> > Flaws
> >
> > 1. decreased power
> > 2. harder to hit the low pitch
> > 3. harder to hit breaking pitches
> > 4. tendency to hit the ball of the end of the bat
> > 5. less batspeed
> > 6. tendency to pull off pitches due to lack of batspeed
> > 7. more likely to go into prolonged slumps
> > 8. more difficult to hit fastballs because the bat is not in the contact zone long enough
> > 9. more difficult to use the whole field with enough power to get the ball out of the infield.
> > 10 requires more upper body strength
>
>
> Coach 13. Would you care to explain your reasons for 7 and 8 under flaws? Thanks.