Posted by: Jack Mankin (>>> I would caution you on postulation built on almost pure conjecture.) on Sat Jun 18 12:48:50 2005

>>> I would caution you on postulation built on almost pure conjecture.
Based on the amount of information you have given, no one could reply with anything more than a "hunch" or a "rough guess". <<<

Hi Ray

I could not agree with you more. Any advice based on someone’s description is just a rough guess. I have received many e-mails from dads describing in detail problems with their son or daughter’s swing and requesting a video analysis. In many cases, what I see in the video was not what I had anticipated from their description.

Even with Major League players, we often find that their description of their swing mechanics does not match what we see. So once again I would agree that advice given on this site is mostly just speculation based on the information given.

Jack Mankin