Posted by: BHL (Knight1285@aol.com) on Tue Nov 9 10:20:21 2004

Hi BHL,
> > >
> > > Thanks for your more detailed explanation. I have to admit that my stubborness stems from my own hitting approach. At 5'8" and 155 lbs and good speed, I am a line drive/gap type hitter, usually 5,6 or 7 in the order - sometimes 2. I don't have the power to be a deep threat on all pitches. My job is to get on base and/or to advance runners. I prefer the opposite field, with most of my extra base hits coming from flares and liners down the line. We play hit-and-run a lot when I am up.
> > >
> > > In contrast to Williams, I have learned to 'look' away and won't swing inside with runners on base and less than two strikes. I'm not a career guy, just a ball player using my assets to contribute to the team, so "history" is immaterial to me.
> > >
> > > Next BP, I'll experiment with your orientation and drill on the inside until then. Who knows?
> > >
> > > Jim
> > > >
> > > > I believe that if a person works on quickness on the inside pitch while standing close to the plate, the hitter can cover over areas of the strike zone easier.
> > > >
> > > > If a person has tremendous bat speed, all they need to do is apply BHT on pitches inside, BHT / THT on pitches down the middle, and THT on outside pitches. If performed correctly, all fastballs can be pulled, regardless of what area of the strike zone that they are thrown in.
> > > >
> > > > I know that Steve Ferroli, a disciple of Ted Williams, argues that a spray-hitter results in the following problem: there is "too much" for the hitter to "learn" and time." He then postulates that this is because, by using this approach, the pitcher can use the "depth" of the strike zone against the hitter. Opposite-field hitting, according to Ferroli, is "a mistake, not an intention," at least the vast majority of the time.
> > > >
> > > > I understand that you express concerns over the bat breaking on inside pitches of this nature; nevertheless, Ferroli postulates that the pull hitter has enough bat speed to have balls that are stroked improperly wind up as "blood hits." In fact, I saw an ESPN reel of Frank Thomas in the past when he was jammed on an inside pitch, and still hit it down the line for a home run.
> > > >
> > > > What about pitches over the middle of the plate? Well, all a hitter has to do is apply slightly more THT to elongate the arms. Although the body will not rotate as much as on an inside pitch, as Mankin points out, the bat will be traveling at a faster speed than an inside pitch due to its wider arc. This means that, although one must always strive for optimal quickness of pitches inside, he or she has more leeway on pitches away from him or her. Following this reasoning, a ball on the middle of the plate will be pulled harder than a ball inside, and one has more time to perform this task correctly.
> > > >
> > > > Finally, on balls that are on the outside corner of the plate, one must apply pure THT to induce the widest sweep of the bat-head; as might be expected, these balls can be pulled with the most authority, despite the fact that the body will not rotate as much.
> > > >
> > > > Now, let's presume for a moment that a pitcher throws a slower pitch than expected. Well, ironically, this puts the pull field orientee at a distinct advantage; he has more time to hit the pitch. Though fooled, a person like Willie Stargell will use the time to generate more bat-speed, as suggested in an article in "Baseball Digest" referencing why some might believe a slow pitch will travel faster than a heater.
> > > >
> > > > I hope this is more detailed, Jim. Thanks for the response, and feel free to ask questions that I did not raise.
> > > >
> > > > BHL
> >
> > Hi Jim,
> >
> > Good luck. And perchance that you have trouble mastering my technique, you can still attempt to "slice" balls over a 300-ft fence, although this will be extremely difficult. I admire your patience, and desire to try new ideas. Personally, I stand at 5'9," and weigh 204 lbs, and am strong, agile, and flexible, as a result of weight-lifting and other exercises. Push yourself even more Jim, and you will not believe the results.
> >
> > Thanks for the curteous and informative response.
> >
> > Cheers!
> > BHL
> ****************************************************************
> Spray hitters come to mind:
> Gwynn, Boggs, Rose, Carew, Jeter, Ichiro
> More than one way to get to Cooperstown.

Hi mb,

I agree there is more than one way to get to Cooperstown. But will people remember Gwynn, Bonds, Rose, Carew, Jeter, Ichiro over Williams, Mac, Bonds, Guerrero, Killebrew, and Mantle, as suggested by Mike Epstein? No. Power-hitters are always given more credence over table-setters.

Honestly, does Ozzie Smith deserve to get in the Hall of Fame based on his defensive prowess, while we deny the great Edgar Martinez, a DH, a great hitter and a defensive liability, a demerit just because one does not like the DH? What about the Maris asterisk? What about refusing to elect Hall of Famers that are purported to have used steroids?

Seen in this light, I have no more right than you to impose my will on who and who does not belong in the Hall of Fame, since they all do.

My point is that the latter will always be remembered over the former.

You raised a great point, though, and I would be delighted to debate with you some more.

BHL