Posted by: Coach C () on Mon Jan 5 21:15:14 2004

Coach C, I have been following the thread as it unravels, and I decided to go back and check your swing to see if I could get a better understanding of some of the things you are talking about.
> > > In your swing, I see no appreciable hip cock or load with your bottom half. I then see a stride of about 10"-11". After toe touch I see your head moving another 4"-5" forward before stopping and going back. I see your bathead centered over your spine half way through your stride and then see the bathead straight up at footplant. Your hands at footplant are much too far from your body to create much power along with the straight up bat.......all that is left is a push with your hands and arms from a less than powerful position. You shoulders are a little too level in the swing, not giving you a chance to swing into the path of the ball........If you want to use your hands as your primary force, I would have them closer to your body and have the hands cocked so that you are closer to having the bathead centered over your spine at footplant. I feel this would be a much more powerful approach than what you have now. Try punching someone from the position your right hand is in at footplant. I am not trying to be tough on you, I just read what you say about your swing and then when I look at it, things look a little different.
> > >
> > > Doug
> >
> >
> > Doug,
> >
> > You are correct. I have emulated many a swing in my day and those are three very differnet swings from one another. I would gladly supply you with the mechanics I describe, if I could get Nick to help me somehow. I have no problem with portraying my swing, which is something I've yet to see you do or anyone else for that matter with the mechanics he professes. You are not being tough on me, because you are correct in those swings. In all three of the swings from the left and right side, the hips are cocking incorrectly, however it served me well in college and kept me above all of my peers in high school.
> >
> > I think the proof in my theories comes through loud and clear when I develop dominate hitters. You will be hearing about most of my players in about two to three more years...trust me! These are kids I've had since they were 10 years old, not great players I pick off the street!
> >
> > Keep pounding away Doug, I can take it.
> >
> > Coach C
> >
> > Hey Coach C
> Very nice reply... that's why i enjoy this forum so much. we put our ideas out there and they get criticized. the criticizee comes back with a civil answer, not bent out of shape defending his position. generally it seems that we all check our egos at the door. i think this can be directly attributed to Jack as i've seen him dissed unmercifally and he comes back calm and rational. his attitude affects us all i believe... thanks, Rich

I agree Rich, Jack is amazing in that regard. Hopefully, we never take these things personally, because other people don't define us. I have no problem with being wrong, but unfortunatley I'm hard to convince.....that's my problem!!! So I live with the consequences.
If I don't put my swing out there, then I may be farther from the truth, so since we can never count on tomorrow....we do what we have to today! Take care and Thank You!

Coach C